Aggressive Litigation Can Result In No Award of Attorneys Fees
Jul 15, 2022
NOELLE MINTO, ESQ.Last month, a new case was decided addressing the ever-important issue of attorneys fees allocation and repayment. As we all know, attorneys fees, like everything have been on the rise. Rates have increased but also the number of hours billed and months lapsed to get cases to trial has also increased. Allocation of attorneys fees cannot merely be an afterthought. Presentation of the case and case management are extremely important in making sure you can succeed in a fee recovery after the fact.
Like so many cases that impact probate and trust law, this case was tried in front of a family law judge as a family law dissolution case. But the real dispute was between the husband and his two siblings. The husband, Daniel, claimed his brought Charleston was hiding his inheritance, which they ultimately agreed a family corporation would owe him $4 million to settle. The siblings’ Taiwanese parents had amassed a $60 million dollar estate Daniel did receive a fees award of $140,000 but when he asked for more it was denied because the court found that he “overlitigated” the case. The dispute with the siblings turned into a dispute over a handwritten agreement and whether it was intended as a final meeting of the minds between the siblings and therefore a binding legal contract. Daniel and his wife each requested fees against the siblings and the family corporation and the vast majority of those fee requests were denied by the court. They found the parties fees were not reasonable because the case was overlitigated. Daniel fought over legitimacy of documents which caused a translator to be required at trial. He also caused trial to go beyond the time estimated by the judge for the trial, which was used against him in the attorneys fees argument. There were other grounds and considerations for the denial of fees based in family law as well. Ultimately Daniel lost his fee requests and the other side got their costs on appeal.
This case is a primary example of the perils of being overly litigious. Particularly when the disputes are not going to cause the litigants to gain ground on a key relevant part of their case, an expert litigator can advise a different approach. Many of our clients at NM LAW are emotional because they are litigating against family members, which is why it is our job to counsel clients which battles will gain ground in the relevant legal dispute and which are perilous or based in emotion and not case strategy. This case is an important lesson in “choosing your battles” and heeding to the advice of sage counsel when litigating with family over personal matters.
For further information on this case, please see the link below.
In re Marriage of Nakamoto & Hsu In re Marriage of Nakamoto & Hsu (79 Cal.App.5th 457).
To speak with our expert probate & trust attorneys, contact us HERE.
Testimonials
John Schroeder was brought on to work on my case with Samantha and they updated/collaborated with Noelle. Noelle, Samantha and John are all patient, direct and very personable. Their knowledge and professionalism are exceptional. NM Law was successful in achieving a Settlement Agreement under difficult circumstances amongst people with little trust in one another. Thankfully we did not have to bear the cost of going to trial, however, I have complete confidence that NM Law would have prevailed if we had.
I highly recommend NM Law. I look forward to working with them again, but this time to plan my estate.
I want to thank you and your staff for the courtesy extended to us during our family's pending emergency deadline.
Mr. O'Grady spoke to my brother and gave us his best recommendation regarding my father's estate.
It is really hard to speak, and even harder to "plan" generational wealth with a parent in terms of assets, intentions, and mortality, but it is a necessary conversation to have, if only to lessen the unfairness of life that eventually catches up to all of us.
Our family tried to bring justice to my father's death within this probate process and found no justice, this system must be changed, so that a fairness is inherit within this system and not just a scam—lots of hard lessons to be learned from a broken probate process.
In either case, thank you again for giving our family the attention and direction we sought. The adage is true, not all lawyers are the same. Looking forward to working with your office in the near future, as we don't want to repeat this experience with our Mom.
Gracias,
Abraham
We highly recommend NM Law for your estate planning needs.
I highly recommend NM Law.
Charities We Support
We dedicate pro bono time, volunteer services, and a percentage of our gross revenue to these organizations. In 2023, we sponsored a refugee family of five to come to the United States and start a new life.
Each year our law firm decides as a group which charities to assist with our time, money, and expertise. Please feel free to click on any of the charities below and make a donation of your own.
